This memo-style essay assesses the seasonal closure of Main Street in downtown Ann Arbor, MI through the lens of Jane Jacobs’ criteria for a vibrant urban space. Public feedback and photos were collected to aid in the analysis in the viability of formalizing and making permanent the pedestrian-only area.  The main strengths of the temporarily closed streets are increased foot traffic and diversity of uses which contribute to safety and a great place to raise a family.  However, while the area is heavily utilized in the summer and fall, its hasty and temporary designation means that the area is not accessible to all.  Inaccessibility and lack of residential space are the main weaknesses of the current plaza and should be addressed if it is turned into a permanent installation.

Comment